Vikings Were Afraid JJ McCarthy Would Demand Trade Last Offseason
The Minnesota Vikings got their 2026 quarterback last week when an invitation for 28-year-old Kyler Murray to visit TCO Performance Center in Eagan quickly resulted in a signed contract and impromptu press conference introducing K1 to the Vikings fans.
It was a money-saving move that offered a long-term upside at QB that others on the market did not. Signing Murray was also a not-so-subtle message to 2024 No. 10 overall pick JJ McCarthy. That if he can’t hang with the new guy, then JJ’s days in a MN Vikings jersey are numbered.
In short, the organization’s approach to strengthening the quarterback room in 2026 was night/day different than what we saw in 2025, when the Minnesota Vikings dismissed multiple starting-caliber quarterbacks, in order to make sure McCarthy had the best possible chance to win the job.
Was JJ McCarthy threatening the Vikings with trade demands last offseason?
Why is KOC approaching this offseason so much different than last year? The easy answer is that McCarthy fumbled his chance to start, and forced the Vikings’ hand. But a peek behind the 2025 curtain may eventually prove that JJ and his representation were also holding a trade threat to organization’s head.
According to Mike Florio (ProFootballTalk), the Minnesota Vikings were afraid, this time last year, that bringing either Sam Darnold or Daniel Jones back in 2026 (or signing Aaron Rodgers), would have resulted in their redshirt rookie demanding a trade out of town.
Last year, when the Vikings were trying to figure out what to do about their quarterback depth chart, there was a concern that McCarthy would possibly ask to be traded, if Sam Darnold or Daniel Jones returned, or if Aaron Rodgers had been signed.
Mike Florio – ProFootballTalk.com
It never really made sense for the MN Vikings to enter training camp last offseason with JJ McCarthy, Sam Howell, Brett Rypien and Max Brosmer as the only quarterbacks in the QB room.
That’s why, last March, insiders across the league expected them to move on a veteran with lots of starting experience — someone who could show him the ropes, push him in training camp and provide insurance for a team ready to win now, just in case the kid QB wasn’t ready.
When they virtually passed on their best veteran options, most of us assumed the Vikings liked what they were seeing from McCarthy early in the offseason, that they didn’t want to block his development with someone who was better in camp, but not long-term.
Are Minnesota Vikings protecting JJ McCarthy’s feelings again?
What we ended up getting was a 23-year-old deer in NFL headlights — who wasn’t ready for big league football mentally or physically. How did the Minnesota Vikings not see that? Turns out, maybe they did know he wasn’t ready, and just didn’t have a choice but to play him anyway… or lose him?
Florio’s report from Monday morning is worth filing away in the mental archives. While the team has acted much more deliberately on improving the QB room, they are still protecting McCarthy’s feelings by creating a narrative that Murray and McCarthy will be competing for the starting job in camp.
Anyone paying attention knows that probably isn’t true. So if they are floating it as a legit QB competition to protect McCarthy… you can’t help but wonder if they are yet again worried that the wrong move could result in a trade demand this offseason?
More About:Minnesota Vikings
